In What Sense Is Hamlet Wrong In His Plotting Against And Killing Of Claudius?

Claudius should have been charged and convicted in a legislative body, through the court. Hamlet had no proof of Claudius’s guilt except for an accusation from a ghost. He was at first too concerned with cold-blooded murder.

He was certain of Claudius’ guilt after he gathered proof, but Hamlet was powerless to do anything except dispatch him. Because he was a harsh king above the law, Claudius posed a significant threat to Denmark’s safety and well-being. It wasn’t simply about payback; it was also about preserving Denmark.

During the time, slogans such as “eye for an eye, death for death” were still appropriate. When Hamlet’s father’s ghost accused him of being poisoned, the demand for vengeance was nothing unusual. Yet there was no assurance that the spirit wasn’t a devil or simply mourning over losing his father in disguise. And there is more to the tale than that.

The key reason why Hamlet is incorrect in plotting against Claudius is that he can’t make up his mind. He overthinks and analyzes too many options before taking any action.

Hamlet would truly be the instrument of death and destruction. What kind of monster or murderer would he become if he fell upon a defenseless opponent? Even at that time when he completely surrendered to genuine regret? A murderer and nothing more. Who would Claudius become in such a scenario? His suffering, a helpless and pathetic victim. Hamlet does not wish to see such a metamorphosis occur.

Hamlet’s murder of Claudius is a result of his impulsiveness, although he considered and weighed the act carefully in this case. Hamlet must immediately dispatch Claudius to save his soul and destroy his own. Hamlet does not murder him for obvious reasons. He needs an unquestionable victory over the opponent, free of misinterpretation

Hamlet’s problem was that Denmark wasn’t ready for a real rebellion. It was a huge prison with many dungeons, and the monarch had no legal authority over it. In particular, such devious kings like Claudius, who was seen as the country’s savior. Each prisoner lived in an atmosphere of complete isolation in which they had to rely only on themselves. The people adore the prince, but they do not rebel. Hamlet rises, but he does not consider the needs of others.

Your reaction


Share this post on social media

Leave a Comment:

Your email address will not be published.



Note: Your password will be generated automatically and sent to your email address.

Forgot Your Password?

Enter your email address and we'll send you a link you can use to pick a new password.