Why Did Catherine Marry Edgar?

Click to rate!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

In the novel Wuthering Heights, Catherine develops romantic attachments for two men. She must pick one of them. Although her feelings for Heathcliff are strong, he cannot offer her the sort of luxurious life she craves. Cathy chooses to marry Edgar in the end, who can improve her social position. The decision has an impact on all of the characters.

The only novel written by Emily Brontë is Wuthering Heights. The narrative features three characters, Catherine Earnshaw, Edgar Linton, and Heathcliff. Catherine and Heathcliff were childhood buddies.

They got closer with time and developed strong feelings for each other. Despite this, Catherine later falls in love with their next-door neighbor, Edgar. This triangle of love introduces the story’s main issue.

Catherine Earnshaw is the illegitimate daughter of a wealthy family who grows up in a quiet hamlet with her siblings. Heathcliff comes to their home when her father brings him there. He has no relatives alive.

Mr. Earnshaw is an uninterested parent who neglects his children. Nonetheless, he dotes on the homeless boy and indulges him excessively. It simply adds to the tension between Heathcliff and the kids. Catherine is the only member of the family who does not despise young Heathcliff. The two like to get away together all of the time.

The two male protagonists occasionally monitor their neighbor Edgar and his sister out of curiosity. Edgar Linton is the polar opposite of Heathcliff. From the moment they first meet, they dislike each other immensely.

The Linton siblings are descended from a prominent background. Catherine and Heathcliff are envious of this fact. The young lady desires desperately to have a prosperous and safe existence. Meanwhile, Heathcliff recognizes that he will never be able to compare to Linton’s money.

After they met Edgar and his sister, the two friends’ connection deteriorated. During their initial encounter with Lintons, Brontë suggests that Catherine and Heathcliff will be divided. When Lintons rescued the girl after their dog attacked her, Catherine and Heathcliff were split up.

When the wealthy neighbors pay them a visit at home, Edgar mockingly laughs at Heathcliff, who returns the favor. Her older brother disciplines him later. The orphan can only stay in Wuthering Heights as a servant to the family after Mr. Earnshaw’s death. His humiliations just make his animosity for Lintons more intense.

Later, Catherine is engaged to Edgar, whom Heathcliff still despises. She tells her housekeeper Nelly that she wants to marry Edgar and not Heathcliff. Marriage offers Catherine the chance to improve her social status. Despite the love and passion she has for him, she believes that marrying him would result in a life of hardship.

Catherine desires to live a lavish lifestyle and be recognized as a respected member of society. As a result, she chooses Edgar’s quiet adoration over Heathcliff’s passionate devotion. Overall, Catherine picks Edgar because he can offer her the life that Heathcliff cannot. She remains devoted to him despite his faults and flaws.

Nonetheless, she admires Edgar for his quiet and kind demeanor. He adores her, and with him, she has more possibilities. Catherine comes to regret her choice later on, but it is too late. The young lady becomes furious with Edgar for shutting Heathcliff out of their lives. Cathy is inconsolable when he leaves, and she dies due to sorrow.

Because Edgar is of a higher social class than Heathcliff, he is the logical choice for one to marry Catherine. In contrast to Heathcliff, who is considered “low,” this makes him more suitable. Her love for Heathcliff is far greater and more vehement than any affection she may have for Edgar.

In Wuthering Heights, Catherine Earnshaw is a mischievous and headstrong youngster. Which emotions are most essential to her? Her feelings for Heathcliff, an adopted member of the Earnshaw family, or Edgar Linton, a devoted suitor of hers, are among them. Catherine has sentiments for both men; however, for two distinct purposes.

Despite her feelings for Heathcliff, Catherine agrees to marry Linton because she believes that she is his, stating, “I am Heathycliff’s; he’s always on my mind.” Catherine is the ideal companion for a conceited and vindictive Heathcliff. Her love for him is the driving force in her life. When she decides to marry Linton, she appears coldhearted, but she is naive enough to believe that by doing so, she will be able to free Heathcliff from Hindley’s clutches.

Catherine has a variety of reasons for marrying Linton. One of her motivations to marry Linton was due to the fact that she and Heathcliff are one and the same. While Linton is different, there is something new. Another reason was that Catherine felt that if she married Linton, she would be able to look after Heathcliff by using his money. They would be beggars if they married Heathcliff, according to Catherine, and they would struggle for money.

I believe that, despite her feelings for Linton, Catherine is only in love and is using him. Hindley has so demeaned him that she believes she’s too good to marry him. The primary reason why Catherine does not marry Heathcliff is that Hindley has desecrated him so much that she thinks she’s better off without him. It seems that Catherine isn’t sure what love means, therefore she marries Linton rather than Heathcliff.